LEVELLAND, Texas — The Air Force file on Levelland opens with a record card. On the Project 10073 card — ATIC Form 329 — the sighting is logged as civilian and ground-visual, its duration given as “3 seconds to 4 mins,” and the conclusion box is ticked: “Other: Ball lightning.” Behind the card sit 82 pages: the record of the night of November 2–3, 1957, when the police department of this High Plains town of about 10,000 logged 15 calls about a glowing object, and driver after driver reported the same thing — as the object came close, the engine died and the lights went out; when it left, both came back.
The calls
The first came from Pedro Saucedo and Joe Salaz, farm workers driving four miles west of town. They told the officer on the night desk, A. J. Fowler, that a blue flash of light had risen near the road and a torpedo- or rocket-shaped object — Saucedo estimated it at about 200 feet long — had passed low over their truck. “I jumped out of the truck and hit the dirt because I was afraid,” Saucedo said. “It sounded like thunder and my truck rocked from the flash… I felt a lot of heat.” The truck’s engine and lights had failed as it passed, and restarted as it moved away. Fowler, believing the story a joke, ignored it.
An hour later, Jim Wheeler reported a brilliantly lit, egg-shaped object, also about 200 feet long by his estimate, sitting in the road four miles east of Levelland and blocking his path. His vehicle died; he got out; the object took off and its lights went out; his car restarted. At 10:55 p.m., a married couple northeast of town reported a bright flash crossing the sky and their headlights and radio dead for three seconds. Jose Alvarez, 11 miles north, reported an object sitting on the road and his engine dead until it departed. At 12:05 a.m., Newell Wright, a Texas Technological College student driving 10 miles east, watched his ammeter jump to discharge and his engine cut out “like it was out of gas” before a 100-foot egg-shaped object he saw sitting in the road; it took off, and his engine ran again. A farmer, Frank Williams, called at 12:15 a.m.; Ronald Martin at 12:45; James Long at 1:15, describing an egg-shaped mass that glowed like a neon sign and shot straight up. At 1:30 a.m., Sheriff Weir Clem saw a brilliant red object move across the sky. Fifteen minutes later, Fire Chief Ray Jones saw an object, and his headlights and engine faltered too. Fowler’s summary of the night stands in the record: “everybody who called was very excited.”
What the file says
The Air Force sent one investigator — a sergeant who spent seven hours in Levelland and interviewed three of the witnesses: Saucedo, Wheeler and Wright. The cars were not examined. The file’s weather summary records an overcast night of drizzle or light rain, in an area that “had been subjected to heavy thunderstorms just prior to the sightings.” The stalls were attributed to moisture on distributor parts, “especially if moisture condensation nuclei were enhanced by increased atmospheric ionization.” One vehicle failure the file does explain in plain mechanical terms: a rotor had been changed on a farmer’s truck the day before, and a piece of the old rotor, left behind, had wedged between the points and disabled the electrical system, according to the mechanic. The investigator’s own working list of possibilities, in a November 7 message, ran to St. Elmo’s fire, burning gas from oil operations reflecting off a 400-foot cloud cover, or a downed power line sparking on wet ground.
The conclusion hardened quickly. Capt. George T. Gregory, the project’s UFO officer, wrote on January 3, 1958 that the phenomenon was “undoubtedly related to the meteorological conditions” — fog, light rain, mist, a low ceiling and lightning discharges — while conceding that ball lightning is “a field, of which very little is known.” The record card’s comments box says the conclusion followed “very extensive checks and detailed investigations.” Inside the file, the treatment of the first witness was brisker: historian Curtis Peebles records Blue Book’s view that Saucedo’s account “could not be relied upon — he had only a grade school education and had no concept of direction.” The same night, at 2:30 a.m., two military police patrols at White Sands Proving Ground in New Mexico reported a bright egg-shaped object hovering near the bunker used in the first atomic bomb test at Trinity Site.
The dispute
The storm is the crux, and it has been disputed for 69 years. James McDonald, an atmospheric physicist who reinvestigated the case, told a House committee in 1968: “Ten vehicles were stopped within a short area, all independently in a 2-hour period. There was no lightning or thunderstorm, and only a trace of rain.” Astronomer Donald Menzel took the other side — “the fiery unknown at Levelland was ball lightning” — while admitting that since ball lightning is short-lived and leaves no tangible evidence, its appearance that night “can never be absolutely proved.” Historians have added a procedural complaint: nine of the fifteen witnesses were never interviewed, and their reports are not covered individually in Blue Book’s final summary.
The most damaging second thought came from inside the project. J. Allen Hynek, Blue Book’s astronomy consultant, wrote in 1977: “I am not proud today that I hastily concurred in [the Air Force’s] evaluation as ‘ball lightning’ on the basis of information that an electrical storm had been in progress in the Levelland area at the time. This was shown not to be the case. Observers reported overcast and mist but no lightning.” He added that there is an “absence of any evidence that ball lightning can stop cars and put out headlights.” The case arrived weeks after the first Sputnik, in a surge of reports the record card itself acknowledged: Levelland, it says, “triggered off more than 300 similarly described reports within a 6 day period” amid nationwide publicity.
What the record holds, 69 years on, is this: fifteen reports, one truck explained by a mechanic, no photograph, no radar return and no physical trace of any object. The ball-lightning label stands in the file. So does its author’s consultant’s regret.
The Facts
- Night of November 2–3, 1957: Levelland police logged 15 UFO reports; drivers reported engines and headlights failing as objects approached and recovering as they left
- Project Blue Book’s record card concludes “Other: Ball lightning”; the stalls were blamed on wet ignition circuits
- The Air Force investigator spent seven hours in Levelland and interviewed three witnesses; nine of the fifteen were never interviewed
- One truck’s failure was traced in the file to a rotor fragment wedged in the distributor points
- Physicist James McDonald told Congress in 1968 there was “no lightning or thunderstorm, and only a trace of rain”
- Hynek, Blue Book’s astronomy consultant, wrote in 1977 that he was “not proud” he had concurred in the ball-lightning finding
Sources: Project Blue Book case file, Levelland, Texas, November 2–3, 1957 (National Archives microfilm, via The Black Vault); J. Allen Hynek, The UFO Experience (1977); James E. McDonald, testimony to the House Committee on Science and Astronautics (1968); Curtis Peebles, Watch the Skies! (1995).





Comments